Voted on by the College Sports Information Directors of America, the Academic All-America At-Large Team recognizes the nation's top student-athletes for their combined performances in athletic competition and the classroom. Finnerty was named as a Second Team CoSIDA Academic All-America selection and is Bowdoin's first At-Large Academic All-American since Kim Kahnweiler in 2016. (Complete release: https://academicallamerica.com/news/2020/6/17/2019-20-academic-all-america-ncaa-division-iii-womens-at-large-team-announced.aspx).
Finnerty was a two-sport All-American for Bowdoin in field hockey and women's lacrosse while excelling in the classroom with a double-major in Government and Legal Studies and Francophone Studies. She received the Athletic Department's Sidney J. Watson Award for Outstanding Multi-Sport Athlete in May.